Papa Joe’s Pizza & Subs

Reviews

• Matthew L.

  star star star star star 23 July 2026

  The Philly cheese steak was great n the pepperoni slice that I had was also very tasty.  I'm pretty picky on both things but the sauce was good and the meat and cheese on the Philly was tasty.  I'll definitely be going back. Was in town for a church conference and skipped over this place a few years but not anymore!

• Ryan D.

  star star star star star_border 13 July 2026

  Really solid slice... large, but very thin slices; and a little 'mushier' than I like typically towards the middle. But because it was nice and crispy towards the crust, the contrast of textures played nicely.
  
  The crust was the all star here, one of the better ones I've had lately, crispy but not overly chewy.
  
  Sauce and cheese were ok, but honestly forgettable even moments later.
  
  The establishment itself is awesome, super clean and inviting. The pizza counter is lined with nice stone work, and there is no shortage of seating if it were busy.
  
  The "Freestyle" Coke machine was a nice touch, as well as they are very popular right now.
  
  I will definitely come back for a slice sometime! Perhaps I'll even go out of my way to do so.
  
  PS- two larger slices and a drink were $5.50 after tax, more than fair!

• Warren N.

  star star star star star_border 10 July 2026

  Homemade bread, homemade desserts, one of those new fangled coke machines and a good philly cheesesteak.  
  
  Easy parking and located near the Harrisburg mall.
  
  Very good.

• Eileen H.

  star star star star star_border 6 July 2026

  This was my first visit, suggested by a friend that has been here before.  We visited for lunch on a Tuesday around 11:30 and the place was dead (which didn't last long--about 15 minutes later people started pouring in!).  They have a bunch of different personal Stromboli's and pizza ready to go under their glass covered counter.  Everything looked very good.  You place your order, pay and then they call your name when your order is ready.
  
  I ordered a steak & cheese personal Stromboli that they had in the case, which was maybe 7 inches long and my friend ordered a salad with grilled chicken.  I got a fountain drink and she got an iced tea from out of the cooler and our bill was just under $20.  My Stromboli was just ok.  My friends loves the salad but it didn't look like something I would've ordered as it had soggy green peppers and a ton of mozzarella cheese on top--but that's just personal taste.  Service was friendly and there was a lot of seating available.  I would like to return and try their pizza!

• Pat B.

  star star star star_border star_border 4 July 2026

  We stopped here for a quick bite while in the area with our kids for a Hershey Park overnight. Place is slow, could use some TLC and the pizza was just ok. Nothing special but close to our hotel.